Why ESG is more important than ever

Many investors are interested in the impact of their investments on the world around them, as well as in the financial performance of the companies in which they invest.

This content is more than 6 months old now, please visit the news area of this site for more recent content

  1. Charles Stanley

Next year, the investment industry in the European Union (EU) will be under a regulatory requirement to take Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) matters into account when making investment decisions about how to generate the best return for the amount of the risk the client is willing to accept.

The EU’s "Regulation on sustainability-related disclosures in the financial services sector" comes into force on March 21 next year. Whilst the duty to seek good investment returns taking into account risks remains central, the manager will also need to consider the impact poor management of ESG matters can have on shares in a company.

It defines sustainability as "good governance and the precautionary principle of do no significant harm, neither environmental harm nor social harm". The aim is for investment to reinforce its ambition to build a circular low-carbon economy. The UK too wishes to encourage ESG informed investing.

ESG makes sense - and always has done

At Charles Stanley, we have been looking into these factors when making investment decisions anyway. It is canny investing to identify risks that come from poor management of a company or from the way it could alienate its customers and the wider communities it serves.

We have seen in recent years the big damage to share prices from the Volkswagen emissions scandal and the BP and oil service industry's problems with the Deepwater Horizon well blow out in the Gulf of Mexico. When companies make large and public mistakes, they end up paying plenty of compensation, suffer reputational damage and spend more on improving their management and governance to prevent a repeat.

All of us are learning how to be more formal in the way we look at these issues and report them. It is no longer satisfactory to rely on common judgements and rumours that Company A is broadly well-intentioned and company B sails close to the wind.

Analysts are combing through much reported data and finding indices and published figures that give insight into how well run and how risky a company is. Rating agencies are providing quantified data summaries of how well companies do. MSCI, for example, rates all main companies relative to their sectors in ESG factors, and awards scores ranging from AAA to CCC as indicators of risk. As more and more people worry about these matters, so we may find further outperformance of the companies that emerge relatively well from such an exercise.

A world of issues

The three main headings of environment, social and governance matters contain such a varied range of issues that a company may score well with one but badly with another. An oil company which emerges badly over carbon dioxide and climate change matters may have excellent governance and good employee relations. An electric car company that is dedicated to cutting CO2 may get a bad score for its board or for it attitude to customers and staff. Whilst the index makers are keen to find objective facts to inform the ratings, there is of course a big element of judgement in what factors are included and how they are assessed. 

Some individuals with strong socially responsible views or ethical values will want to go further than having a good score on ESG matters and they may wish to express a strong preference against various activities they dislike. The EU approach will require asset managers to spell out what their policy is to integrate sustainability into their investment process and ensure good reporting of the ESG impact of the chosen investments. Ratings agencies are producing guides to company performance based on data which managers can use to choose their shares and report to their clients the results.

It is likely as we go into the next year that more asset managers will want to show compliance and will wish to reflect some of the trends this is likely to encourage. The green or environmental part of this movement is anyway being boosted by public policy and the likelihood of a Biden win in the US. Investors are also very concerned about corruption and company management that cuts corners in everything from health and safety to employee relations, so managers need to consider the ‘S’ and ‘G’ as well as the ‘E’ seriously.

Companies scoring well on ESG have, in aggregate, gently outperformed this year and may continue to do so as we approach implementation time in Europe. This week, the EU Council took another step towards accelerating the EU’s progress to net-zero carbon. This will be a dominant influence on investments over the next few years, as carbon fuel-related investment is wound down and written off, and green investment is subsidised and expanded.

Nothing on this website should be construed as personal advice based on your circumstances. No news or research item is a personal recommendation to deal.

More from author

  1. Charles Stanley

    The EU gets serious about net zero

    Date: 16th Oct 2020 13:20pm

    The Green revolution is wide-ranging and will have a huge impact on all our lives and...

  2. Charles Stanley

    Why ESG is more important than ever

    Date: 16th Oct 2020 13:20pm

    Many investors are interested in the impact of their investments on the world around ...

  3. Charles Stanley

    A new orthodoxy may emerge in the US

    Date: 16th Oct 2020 13:20pm

    America goes to the polls to elect its next president on 3 November. Although the vot...

Most read articles

  1. Why ESG is more important than ever

    The EU gets serious about net zero

    Date: 16th Oct 2020 13:20pm

    The Green revolution is wide-ranging and will have a huge impact on all our lives and...

  2. Why ESG is more important than ever

    Why ESG is more important than ever

    Date: 16th Oct 2020 13:20pm

    Many investors are interested in the impact of their investments on the world around ...

  3. Why ESG is more important than ever

    Wind in the UK’s sails?

    Date: 16th Oct 2020 13:20pm

    Despite COVID-19, dividend hunters continue to back the green revolution.

Investment involves risk. You may get back less than invested.